Hiya,
Today I want to talk a little about something I call ‘career fear’. That feeling you get when your child tells you what they’d like to do when they grow up, and you really want to be encouraging, but you’re actually thinking…errrr, you want to do what? Good luck paying your rent with that 😅
Most of us learned which jobs were ‘good’ jobs very early on. You’d hear grown-ups talking about someone’s daughter getting into medical school or law school, and you could tell from the way they talked that it was a VERY GOOD THING. Whereas if you were good at drawing, you could have those same adults telling you for years how talented you were, how much they loved your work, how you should do more of it…right up until you mentioned you’d quite like to do it for a living.
At which point it probably changed to something like...”Really? Are you sure? Maybe you could just do it on the side…”
This career conditioning goes deep. We can spend years questioning what we were told about school, about what our children need to learn, about who gets to decide what a good education even is, and feel pretty good about where we’ve got to with all that. Then one of our kids says they’d quite like to be an artist and…oh, umm, really? Are you sure?
So today I want to see if we can unwind a little of that. Because if we’re going to steer our child away from something, it’s important we understand where that instinct comes from and whether, actually, we truly agree with it.
Let me try something with you. Imagine your fifteen-year-old tells you they’d quite like to be a vet. What’s the first thing you’d say to them?
I reckon most of us would be pretty encouraging, right? We’d ask what kinds of animals they’d like to work with, what the pathways and options are, and whether they’d like to come along next time we take the dog in so they can ask the vet a few questions themselves.
And I’m quite sure very few of us would say, “Oh, that’s cool! And what will you do if that doesn’t work out? What’s your plan B?”
Now take the same child, same age, and have the same conversation about what they’d like to do when they grow up (which, of course, is fast approaching at that age) - but this time they tell you they’d quite like to be a musician. No, actually, they really want to be a musician.
Same reaction? Same feeling? Same support and encouragement? Be honest with yourself.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot recently, because this is the career our sixteen-year-old wants. He’s been playing piano since he was about eight, he plays guitar and the drums and jams on his ukulele, and he’s strongly considering studying music more formally next year. He wants some formal tuition, he wants to meet other musicians, and he wants to see where he can take this thing he’s already spent a fair chunk of his life doing.
And all the conversations we’ve had around this stuff have got me wondering where we get our ideas about which paths children should be encouraged down, and which ones they’d be wise to have a backup plan for. Because by the time a child is old enough to tell us what they’re interested in, a lot of us already have some pretty firm ideas about how sensible certain things are or are not.
I remember this really clearly from my own school years. If you were doing well academically, the expectation was that you’d go to university. What you’d actually study there, whether you’d actually enjoy it, whether it would lead to work you actually wanted to do…well, you could figure all that out along the way. That wasn’t the most important thing. Just going there was.
(I spent four years studying almost every subject under the sun at Uni, and came out with a massive student loan and no degree to show for it, so I can personally vouch for there being a few holes in that idea 😂)
But if that same very academically capable kid wanted to go into a trade, the message almost certainly would have been that they’re selling themselves short. Which is really quite odd, when you think about it. If a child was good with their hands and good at maths, how did that make becoming a builder a worse idea for them? You’d think their future clients might be quite happy about that combination of skills, actually.
And yet plenty of us grew up with exactly that kind of messaging. So when our own children tell us what they’d like to do, some of what feels to us like good, sensible parental judgement is often just a faithful account of what the adults around us thirty years ago thought.
There’s something else in this, too, which comes back to that vet and musician question.
When you picture someone making a living as a vet, who comes to mind? Probably the person down the road you took your dog or cat to recently, right? An actual person, in an actual place of work, who you’ve personally handed an eye-watering sum of money to. You have a pretty good idea how they earn a living because you’ve contributed to it 😅
But who did you picture when I said musician? Because if you pictured someone playing to thousands of people in a stadium, hang on a second…when did your child say anything about wanting to be famous? All they said was they’d love to play music for a living.
How come the person who played at your wedding didn’t come to mind? Or the person you pay to teach your child piano every week? What about the drummer down in the orchestra pit when a touring musical comes through town, while you’re outside lining up to buy a pricey ticket? What about the singer who recorded that stupidly catchy jingle from that ad? Or the person who makes the backing tracks you sing along to at karaoke? Or whoever wrote the music for the video game your child’s been playing for the last three months (the one you can now hum despite never having played the game yourself)? What about the musician who gets paid when a company licenses one of their tracks for a training video? Or the independent artist you’ve never heard of - and probably never will - who makes a good living from their own back catalogue because enough people listen to it on Spotify month after month?
There’s actually a very good chance you’ve helped a musician pay their rent, too.
Of course, if my son wants to earn a living from music, how people actually do that is a very important thing for us to talk about. I want him to have some idea of what people get paid for, how regularly the different types of work come in, what they typically spend their week doing, whether he’d enjoy that life as much as he enjoys sitting down at the piano and playing what he wants to his heart’s content…they’re all important, worthwhile questions to ask.
But think back to what we were probably going to do for the child who wanted to be a vet. We were going to take them along next time we went to see what the work was like. They’d get to ask their questions, see some of the good bits and probably a few fairly unpleasant bits, and come home knowing more about whether this was something they actually wanted to do.
(an experience we had with our daughter, actually, who took one look at what a vet does in person and pivoted to becoming a service dog trainer 😂)
So couldn’t we do exactly that for the child who wants to be a musician? We could have a conversation about how hard it is to earn a living from music, what else they might like to do, how sensible it would be to have something to fall back on…and never once say “Hey, you know what, let’s find a couple of people who do this for a living and see if they’d be up for a chat.”
Maybe our child comes home from that even more excited about the idea. Maybe, like my daughter, they find out there’s a lot about the day to day reality they wouldn’t love. Either way, they’ve got something to go on beyond how we felt (as we noticeably tensed) when they first mentioned it.
So if you ever feel that funny old career fear conditioning kicking in, ask yourself this:
If they’d told me they wanted to do something I personally felt more comfortable with, what would I have helped them do next?
Then…go do that.
Talk soon,
Issy.
P.S. There’s a bigger question here that I go into in my episode Why ‘get a good job’ is bad advice (and what to tell our kids instead). The working world has changed massively, and ‘work hard to get good grades and land a good job’ is no longer the best advice. So…what do we tell our children now? This ep is almost an hour long, looking at how work is changing and how people are choosing to make a living in very different ways.
And if you’d like to join us, you can get the full Collection and access to my private community right here.
